Box Score St. Louis, Mo. – The University of Findlay women's soccer team returned to action for the second round of the NCAA Division II Tournament on Saturday, November 14, with a spot in the Midwest Regional final on the line. Facing top-seeded host Missouri-St. Louis, the Oilers were unable to contain the Tritons' explosive offense, falling by a score of 3-0.
With the loss, Findlay's first since September 17, its second-ever NCAA Tournament appearance comes to an end. The Oilers conclude the 2026 season with a record of 14-3-5, including a 9-1-4 mark in Great Midwest Athletic Conference (G-MAC) play.
Despite facing the No. 1 seed in the region, the Oilers came out aggressively, applying pressure early and creating several scoring opportunities. Just two minutes into the contest, senior
Allie Arnold nearly gave the Orange and Black a 1-0 lead, but her shot from outside the box struck the crossbar, narrowly missing the back of the net.
Missouri-St. Louis quickly responded, finding the back of the net just four minutes later to take a 1-0 lead in the sixth minute. The Tritons doubled their advantage in the 20th minute when Ella Anselm netted her second goal of the match. Findlay generated a few more opportunities before the break but entered halftime trailing 2-0.
The Oilers continued to battle coming out of the break, putting two shots on goal in the 47th and 48th minutes. However, Great Lakes Valley Conference (GLVC) Goalkeeper of the Year Allysa Wolf turned away both attempts to preserve the Tritons' lead.
UMSL added an insurance goal in the 73rd minute, capitalizing on a corner kick to extend its advantage to 3-0, which would stand as the final score.
Leading Findlay offensively with three shots apiece were
Raegan Smith and
Avary Zeisloft.
Fifth-year goalkeeper
Cat Graves continued to battle in net, recording six saves to keep the Oilers within reach. Graves capped off a historic season with 13 shutouts, tying the program's single-season record.
Despite the season-ending result, the Oilers have plenty to be proud of following a memorable 2026 campaign. Findlay's win total of 14 is the most since the 2019 season, reaching the NCAA Tournament for the second time in program history.